The New York Yankees are in dire need of a first baseman.  The Chicago White Sox apparently want to possibly ship out Nick Swisher according to this.  And if the Yankees are to let Bobby Abreu walk, then the team could have some serious options in the outfield with Matsui, Damon, Nady, Swisher (if needed, in right, at first, DH) and Gardner as a utility outfielder, or Gardner could start in center if he is worthy.  I am not advocating that the Yankees MUST trade for Nick Swisher.  I am simply saying that he is an option, and can solve a few different problems.  The final say would be Brian Cashman pulling the trigger, and what the Yankees would have to give up in order to land Swisher.

     The optimist says…Nick Swisher is a much better player than he was this season.  And I truly believe that.  As random baseball analyst says, Swisher had a definite down year, however his underlying numbers point to a flukey “down year.”  Nick Swisher fits nicely into the Yankee “philosophy,” woking the count and getting on base.  Not to mention, Swisher does possess some power in his swing.  Swisher also happens to be a switch hitter which is always welcome.  So the majority of the time he would be aiming at a short porch.  Another positive in Swisher is that he is just entering his prime.  Obviously, a team wants players as close to their prime as possible, and Swisher is right in the midst of what should be his best seasons.  Financially, Swisher is locked up to a club friendly contract, assuming he produces: $5.3 million in 2009, $6.75 in 10,’ and $9 million in 2011 (plus a 2012 option).  Then, Swisher being a pretty good player, but nothing special would most likely be allowed to leave via free agency after either 2011, or 2012 depending on if they pick up the option or choose to pay $1 million to let him walk.  Looking down the road, he would probably not be worth re-signing for the years in which he would start his decline.  Another positive, or negative, depending on how one looks at it, is that Swisher should be more of a “buy-low” than in most years.  After all, he had a down year, and should not cost as much as in other productive seasons. 

     The pessimist…Nick Swisher had a down year, again, a DOWN YEAR.  So maybe there is a reason for concern that no one knows about.  Maybe he doesn’t care.  Maybe he cares more about other aspects of his life.  Maybe he hates baseball.  Maybe the only reason he was any good, was because of some kind of PED (half-joking, but it can never be ignored it seems).
     Another downside is that Swisher does strike out quite a bit, however not like a Ryan Howard or Adam Dunn do, just enough to make most fans hate him during his slumps.  And as a career .244 hitter, fans might hate him a little more.  But I am worried about OBP, and Swisher has always done that well.  The casual fan does not seem to care about the walks, just the strikeouts and batting average.  But then again, this isn’t really about the “casual” fan. 

     Nick Swisher is simply an “option” for a team that needs a few pieces.  Go after Teixera first, but there is a price that not every team will be willing to agree to.  If Tex wants $200 million, then I would be hesitant to give, even if I was the most financially adept? major league club.  And of course, the price that the Yankees would have to succumb to matters a lot. 

     Of course, Swisher is a need that other teams have, too.  The Mets could use him at a corner outfield spot for a year, then move him to first when Delgado leaves after the season.  And others could use him as well.  Swisher is nothing special, but I believe he will be a solid major leaguer for the remainder of his contract.  And the Yankees popped in my head first, probably because they are the team most closely related to a Red Sox fans mind.     


  1. mikeeff

    as a regular customer here i DO appreciate the service 😉

    nick swisher is one of those players everybody seems to like- a fun guy with a high OBP. he’s even got some pop–but man did he have an awful year- i even noted his OBP dropped as well as his average. i suppose one could do worse, but frankly i guess i’d keep the big G over him for 1st base–i know his D is better than giambi’s but the big G wasn’t terrible playing there this year. but you did make me think–if the guy really can play CF he might not be a bad fit for the yanks–i love brett gardner, but he’s proven nothing. i’m hoping the little steins open the war chests and get tex as well as CC and another starter–IMO that starter should be ollie perez.

    your idea about him being a fir for the mets is a good one, but they re-signed tatis for LF

    ( thanks for helping us take FL yesterday )

  2. joefromnewhampshire

    Swisher can play center field, but I don’t know how good he is. He wasn’t in the bottom of the Plus/Minus system, so he must be at least “not terrible” at it. But he is flexible because he can play outfield and 1st base, and of course DH. But anyone can DH I guess, haha. Giambi isn’t a bad option, but if they are trying to shed some payroll then Swisher the next three years will be paid what Giambi will be paid THIS season. Of course Giambi would not cost anything other than money.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s