Dice K…was decent?

     I wasn’t entirely disappointed with Daisuke Matsuzaka last night.  I know that he did not quite make it five innings and got the quick hook from Francona.  That was partially because it was the playoffs, but also because there were many pitchers awaiting in the pen and everyone was available.  And every one of those pitchers that were used, or could have been used, have a day off today. 

     It wasn’t like they were hitting ropes all over the field.  Chone Figgins had a bloop single that fell in front of Manny, and Cabrera had a routine fly ball that turned out to be a double, as Manny was playing incredibly shallow yet again.  Garret Anderson also added a bloop double that bounced out of Drew’s glove on a nice attempt for a sliding catch.  He also had a borderline pitch on a 3-2 count to Cabrera in the first that was called ball four.  But the TBS version of the "K-Zone" showed it was a strike.  The Angels actually had a very good approach at the plate early against Matsuzaka.  They had never seen him, and they made him throw pitches.  Give credit to them for that.  But when fans watch "Sportscenter" and see Matsuzaka getting pulled just shy of five innings, they will probably think he was terrible.  And he wasn’t. 

     Should I give out my Gold Gloves?  Or should I ignore it because I don’t have enough information?  The voters should just rely on statistics mostly in my opinion on this matter.  I know defensive statistics are not what offensive stats are, but the voters do not have enough of a sample of [every] defender to judge these.  Just a thought, because if Jeter wins another Gold Glove it will make them seem that much more meaningless.  If nothing else, speak to John Dewan before you cast your vote. 

     VORP?  I don’t know how much I like this stat.  What it does is give the offensive value over that of a replacement player.  So if there is a great offensive shortstop, who has the same offensive stats as a first baseman, the shortstop will have the higher VORP.  Which is fine, but it doesn’t take into account defense.  So the shortstop could be awful on defense and switching positions would be best for the team, yet based on this stat his value will be very high regardless.  By the way, it stands for "Value over Replacement Player," to be exact.  And I understand what it is showing.  It is easier to find a first baseman who can hit then that of a shortstop.  Simply because it is harder to play shortstop.  But I would much rather look at "Win Shares" because it does take into account defensive performance.  And a shortstops defensive value will be based on how much he does for the team, rather than just simply being in between the second and third baseman.



  1. tswechtenberg@gmail.com

    well i hope for dice-k’s sake people drop in here to get the real skinny on his performance before they wander over to sportscenter. i suppose you’re right. decent. i think francona took him out at the right time. he might have disintegrated at any moment. i thought his use of the pen last night was extremely deft. every move perfect. i didn’t understand going to pap in the 8th in a tie game as i said before, but i suppose you don’t have a comment on that.
    no comments on the effect of the anti-bartman either?

    i’m not trying to imply anything. your team was awesome last night. i was very impressed.

    so i hope you have an open thread for the sunday night game.

    also, what are your thoughts on all the days off between games

  2. levelboss@levelboss.com

    Joseph, i apologize for my comment yesterday on Jason’s blog.. i was just irritable, and i hope you’ll forgive me

  3. joseph

    I was fine with Okajima, but turning to Pap wasn’t a big deal at the time in my opinion. Okajima may be on a strict pitch count of some kind. He had the fatigue down the stretch as you know, and had thrown 24 pitches, so maybe 25 was his max or something, I don’t know. But Okajima was pitching well and leaving him in for one more out wasn’t a big deal to me. But turning to Papelbon wasn’t terrible either, this is the playoffs. He hadn’t pitched in a while. Francona managed the pen well, as he did in the 04′ playoffs. I don’t know why he can’t do this consistently throughout the season.

  4. tswechtenberg@gmail.com

    i guess what i was getting at was, what if the game went into extra’s. he would have had to use gagne i guess. anyway. it all worked out.

  5. joseph

    Or Timlin. I understand where you are coming from, I was definitely considering that at the time too. I guess Francona thought that he had a good chance of scoring a run in one of the next two at bats, I thought we could too. But he really had to go to Papelbon in the ninth right? So he only brought him in for that extra out, which unfortunately took a little longer then it should have.

  6. tswechtenberg@gmail.com

    you know when you boil it down, you’re right. who else other than pap for the ninth. if you go into extras, so be it, but win now with your best. and yeah, it could have been one pitch, one out for him in the 8th but for that throw.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s