Blown game, and Jeter vs. Mauer

     I would have to say that I was a little disappointed last night.  Had there been no Wild Card, I would have had the same face that many of those fans at Fenway displayed.  But as angry as I became, I made myself take a look at the big picture.  And that picture being that the Red Sox have an eight game lead over the Tigers for that final playoff spot. 

     The Yankees earned every bit of that win though.  They beat the two best bullpen arms we had to offer.  And beat them quite well.  Okajima has not been the same lately.  He does not command his pitches anymore it seems, and deception alone is not going to work on its own, the second time around the league. 

     Papelbon came in when the game was on the line.  This is the great sabermetric debate.  Sabermetricians want to use there closer when the game is on the line, whether it be the 8th or 9th inning, or even the 7th in some cases.  The closer role has been defined improperly.  They seem to be saved until the 9th, and some only want them to come in with the lead at hand.  I disagree, and lean toward those guys running the Saber-conventions on this particular issue.  We also had Manny Delcarmen if we needed him for the ninth inning, and Eric Gagne crossing his fingers out in the bullpen also.  Had Papelbon held the lead in the 8th, and either Gagne or Delcarmen  had come into blow the game, it still would have been the right move.  It was difficult enough, as shown by the game itself, for arguably the best closer in baseball to handle this situation.  So why would I want Delcarmen (young/inexperienced) or Gagne (not reliable of late) to come into this.  Starting them fresh in the ninth with the lead would have been more logical I would think. 

     The Yankees are not in Papelbon’s head, I don’t think anyway.  They may be in Okajima’s head though.  Or it may have been the fact, as mentioned, that he was not locating his pitches, and has not been.  Or he could just be [this] pitcher.  Teams have seen him more now, and they have grown a little more comfortable, especially Robinson Cano.  Cano seems to like to crush balls to straight away center off Okajima in crunch time.   


     "Heartland" and I were having a friendly little debate as to who the MVP should have been last season.  He of course was on Jeter’s side, and I, as I have spoken of in past blogs, was in defense of the great Joe Mauer.  It isn’t as if I think Jeter would have been a bad choice, because that is definitely not the case.  Morneau was debatable, and it was definitely a close race.  But let me state a few reasons why I thought Mauer deserved it. 

     The catcher is the most important position on the field.  Can we all agree on that?  Eliminating the current pitcher for this discussion.  There is one thing that cannot be measured accurately from a catcher, and that is game calling skills.  We can browse various statistics such as "Catcher ERA," etc.  But with a pitcher like Johan Santana throwing to you, it may not be all that imperative, as he may command control of his repertoire.  But he did work with young pitchers as well, Liriano, and others.  But based on reputation, he is a good caller of a game.  I do not see him much, so I am going to listen to the experts more so on this one.  There are a few things I don’t like to touch on; managers and game calling skills.  Without a large sample for either, I don’t feel I have enough information to come up with an accurate conclusion.  But let me just say, it matters how much one values the ability to call a game.  And it matters how well one thinks Joe Mauer in particular did it. 

     Statistically, both were great offensive players, especially in respect to their positions.  Mauer had an OPS+ of 144, which fell in at 7th in the AL, actually three slots ahead of his MVP teammate Justin Morneau.  Jeter was at 138 in this category, right outside the top ten.  Mauer only had 8 stolen bases, which is little compared to Jeter’s 34.  Jeter stole them at an incredible rate of 87%, Mauer was at 73%.  And remember, we statisticians value OBP more than Slugging.  Sabermetricians to be more accurate.  I enjoy all statisitics, not just the ones that the average person has no idea of (Win Shares).  But the OBP battle was very close, with Mauer at .429 and Jeter at .417.  RISP went to Jeter as he batted .381 to Mauer’s .360.  Jeter was second best in this category in the AL, Mauer was fourth.  Michael Young somehow batted .412 in these situations.  The one large advantage that Jeter has over Mauer on the offensive side of the ball is in "Runs Created."  Jeter "Created" 138, while Mauer "only" created 106. 

     There are a few other things that I believe in, when discussing the very debatable (in most years anyway) MVP award.  One being intangibles.  Both seem to display positive intangibles.  Jeter’s are definitely magnified as he plays in the city of New York, and rightfully so.  His leadership qualities should be praised, but at times he gets a little too much credit as a winner.  I don’t know how to put this, but Jeter is a winner.  He seems to produce when it matters most, as much as anyone in the game.  But he has also had plenty of help, having the most talented team in baseball surrounding him most years.  So while he, the veteran who has more experience gets the edge in this category, it isn’t some huge advantage on Jeter’s part.  If it was Jeter vs. Milton Bradley or Elijah Dukes, he would blow them away.  Barry Bonds might blow Dukes away in this category, and that is sad.  But Jeter and Mauer are both good guys who seem like they want to lead.  But then again I have seen Jeter  a lot more than I have seen Mauer play, and I am not in the dugout, so it isn’t easy to compare these intangibles. 

     As I mentioned Jeter has had a lot of help in the past and currently.  And once again sabermetricians don’t believe in protection much.  While I do!  And Mauer had one of the best hitters in baseball behind him, but he did not have the same kind of overall protection up and down the lineup that Jeter had, not even close.  Any Yankee has an advantage in this category over any other player in baseball.  First, I find it hard to believe that sabermetricians could find a study that could accurately give them enough information to see whether protection does exist through statisitics.  It is more left up to the naked eye, and even that is tough to see at times.  But my logic says that if there is a guy on base and Manny Ramirez is coming up that I am going to try and pound the strike zone a little more than if the bases are empty.  And Jeter comes across these situations more so than Joe Mauer, right?  Protection is still left up to the imagination a little, as to how valuable it is, but I believe it should be valued more highly than the likes of Rob Neyer and Bill James do.  Anyway, Jeter has a rather large advantage in this category, meaning Mauer has a large disadvantage, so Mauer gets the edge, seemingly having slightly less of an opportunity to succeed.  Or at least is not put in the same position to succeed as Jeter. 

     But this award could have gone to a few different participants.  While everyone is a participant I guess, but there was more than one worthy of the award.  And this isn’t because I dislike the Yankees.  As of now, I would give [this] seasons MVP trophy to ARod.  I am staying objective, I think anyway.  But my defense of Mauer went on a little longer than I had originally planned.  So I must conclude, only with the possibilty of starting another blog. 



    i don’t know why all these bloggers and sportswriters are screaming about francona losing his head and putting pap in when he did. i know i already said this at BPS, but with guys on 2nd and third and nobody out it would be insane NOT to use pap. if he had gotten out of the inning unscathed then i think delcarmen could have easily closed it out. francona declared a hero and dancing in the streets of boston. i know you have your problems with your manager but i think we agree here. what i don’t understand about him was why, if he was going to bring okajima back in the 8th, why wouldn’t you have other guys at least warming up? he has to know that we’ve hit oka pretty hard lately and apparently so have other teams, so why not have a couple of options to go to?

    mauer is an incredible player and i would agree that he was more valuable than morneau was to the twins last year. but listen, after reading your blog today, you have me convinced that jeter should have won it.

  2. Jason

    Joseph, I felt for you after the game, and know last night wasn’t an easy one to take. I don’t think that the Yanks are in Papelbon’s head, either, but Okajima’s is possible. He clearly seemed strike-zone shy after the Giambi and Cano homers. Last night had a strange feel to me, especially in the HDLR. The guy dropping in the Kerry stats about Gaelic soccer championships was like the guy parachuting into the ring during the Bowe-Holyfield fight.

    Being the “Heartland” persona on the other side of the 2006 MVP discussion–and it certainly was a friendly disagreement–I don’t believe that Mauer would have been a bad choice, and probably was as worthy as Morneau. My case for Jeter is certainly based on proximity to a degree, and how he carried the team consistently as so many players were inconsistent and injured. But in fairness to Jeter in the “protection” department, the Twins had huge years around Mauer last year. Morneau was 34-130-.321, Hunter 31-98-.278, Cuddyer 24-109-.284. The rest of the supporting cast, true, wasn’t nearly the same, but the heart of the Twin’s order around Mauer was certainly comparable. I’m less sold on that part of the pro-Mauer argument than, say, his capacity as a catcher, and he was clearly very good defensively and with a good staff. I would also add that Jeter carries a lot of gravitas in the “intangibles” department, while Mauer has his own abilities there, too.

    Don’t get me wrong–I’m not saying Mauer wasn’t MVP worthy, just that Jeter–also in a highly important position at SS–would have received my vote. In addition to his great hitting last year, stealing 34 of 39 shouldn’t be overlooked as an all-around offensive threat. That said, I didn’t exactly lose sleep this winter over Morneau receiving the MVP over Jeter. I also think your case for Mauer is well stated.

  3. joseph

    My blog should have convinced you Mike that there was no clear choice for MVP šŸ™‚

    I chose Mauer but there are other deserving candidates as well.

    Oops, I meant meant “pound the strike zone a little more than if the bases are empty” meaning that I dont have to give into a hitter with a base open.


    seriously, i was disappointed for jeter that he didn’t win last year, as i think it was one of his best. to his credit i really believe he much more interested in winning games for the team than any personal achievements. of course that is just the kind of attributes which make him an MVP. morneau was certainly deserving as was mauer.

    re-reading the first part of your blog i get the impression that you think the yanks might take the division. is this true?

  5. joseph

    No. But the urgency is not the same with the Wild Card. I think Manny may very well have played this series had there been no Wild Card. I also think that we would have been more apt to trade for Dye to make sure we made the playoffs. I think it is a slightly different philosophy when there is a Wild Card. Every division leader knows they have that to fall back on. That is my personal viewing of it anyway.


    well i think they traded for gagne to make sure they made the playoffs…or perhaps it would be more reasonable to say to make sure they won once they got to the playoffs. i don’t know who the white sox wanted for dye, but they surely weren’t going to give up a treasure like ellsbury

  7. joseph

    It wasn’t ellsbury from what I heard. It was actually less than what I had originally thought. I had heard they wanted Wily Mo and Justin Masterson at first. Materson is supposed to be a very good reliever. I heard last week in Buster Olneys blog that the White Sox would have done it without Masterson included, meaning that some other pieces would have been included, but it would be less to give up from our standpoint than the original trade included from the way Olney made it sound.

    I don’t know if I made it clear though what I said. The odds on making the playoffs are greater with the Wild Card being around, obviously. So I believe had there been only two opportunites, by the old playoff format, to make the playoffs teams would panic a little more. If they get into the playoffs that is what really matters now. So it isn’t as if I don’t want to win the division, but without the Wild Card some teams would fold and sell off there parts a little sooner, etc. My own personal take I guess.


    wow, i can’t believe they might have been willing to give up dye for so little.

    and yeah , you have been clear…just making conversation here..


    you know i’ve heard talk about perhaps making the trade deadline a few weeks later in the season so teams would have a better idea of where they stand and might be more likely to make some changes. i’m not even sure that would make a difference because as you point out…so many teams stay in the race because of the WC.

    so i’m sitting here listening to pedro/mets game while i wait for this afternoon’s battle

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s